| Title | Trophy | Description |
| “I am Batman.” | Platinum | Collect all Trophies |
| “A hero can be anyone.” | Gold | Complete Story Mode |
| “Hopefully, because he’s busy.” | Gold | Complete every side activity in Gotham |
| A Watchful Collector | Gold | Collect all Collectibles |
| “I’m not wearing hockey pads.” | Silver | Unlock All Suits |
| “Wanna know how I got these cars?” | Silver | Unlock All Vehicles |
| “Holy Skill Upgrades, Batman!” | Silver | Unlock All Skill Upgrades |
| “This is too much power for one person.” | Silver | Collect all Red Bricks |
| Up for the Challenge | Bronze | Complete 20 Challenges |
| “It’s a big city. I can’t be everywhere.” | Bronze | Unlock all fast travel points |
| A Friend | Bronze | Unlock Jim Gordon |
| “Hear me roar.” | Bronze | Unlock Catwoman |
| The Boy Wonder | Bronze | Unlock Robin |
| “Let’s see what Batgirl can do!” | Bronze | Unlock Batgirl |
| A Grayson Graduation | Bronze | Unlock Nightwing |
| Out of the Shadows | Bronze | Unlock Talia |
| “It’s not exactly a normal world.” | Bronze | Visit every District |
| Wonderful Toys | Bronze | Purchase all Gadget Upgrades for any single character |
| Beware the Gray Ghost! | Bronze | Complete Bruce’s Gray Ghost costume |
| “A legend, Mr. Wayne.” | Bronze | Complete the Prologue |
| One Bad Day | Bronze | Complete Chapter One |
| “Do I look like I’m joking?” | Bronze | Complete Chapter Two |
| The Dynamic Duo | Bronze | Complete Chapter Three |
| An Endless Winter | Bronze | Complete Chapter Four |
| Knightfall | Bronze | Complete Chapter Five |
| “You have a name to maintain.” | Bronze | Open every WayneTech Cache |
| “The idea was to be a symbol.” | Bronze | Collect 25 Bat-Symbols |
| “Quite the collection, Master Bruce.” | Bronze | Collect all Batcave Trophies |
| Too Many Questions | Bronze | Complete every Puzzle Room |
| “Lighter, faster, more agile.” | Bronze | Purchase a Skill Upgrade from each category |
| Theatricality and Deception | Bronze | Purchase 3 Gadget Upgrades |
| “I own the place.” | Bronze | Purchase all Batcave Expansions |
| Not Just a Cave | Bronze | Place 5 Props or Trophies in the Batcave |
| “No, sir. The OTHER car.” | Bronze | Purchase 3 Vehicles from the Batcave |
“You either buy a hero…” | Bronze | Purchase 5 Items from Shops |
| “Does it come in black?” | Bronze | Equip a Red Brick |
| “Wouldn’t wanna make things too easy.” | Bronze | Get 5 Gold Medals in AR Trials |
| Rebuilding Gotham | Bronze | Cash in a Challenge in the Batcave |
| Collecting Evidence | Bronze | Roll the camera over 20 degrees in Photo Mode |
| Computer Privileges | Bronze | Change the screensaver on the Batcomputer |
| “Life’s been good to me.” | Bronze | Collect 1,000,000 Studs |
| Caped Defender | Bronze | Perform 100 Successful Counters |
| “Never do it for free.” | Bronze | Collect 30,000 Studs within a single stud combo |
| “I’m good with calculation.” | Bronze | Maintain Max Stud Combo for 60 Seconds |
| The Strength to Fight | Bronze | Reach Combat Combo of 99 hits |
| “I am the shadows.” | Bronze | Perform 100 Stealth Takedowns |
| “This is my city.” | Bronze | Place a Pin on the Map |
| “You’re becoming quite a celebrity.” | Bronze | Discover 100 open world events |
| Cowardly and Superstitious Lot | Bronze | Defeat every type of enemy once |
| “Gotham can feel a little safer.” | Bronze | Prevent 30 Crimes |
| “Things have improved.” | Bronze | Prevent each type of Crime in Gotham once |
| “Is that like parachuting?” | Bronze | Glide in 10 different wind tunnels |
